Small Town Murder
True crime podcast review — 2026
Reviewed
"Small Town Murder gets the comedy-crime balance right in a way most try and fail to achieve. James and Jimmie are genuinely funny, but they actually care deeply about the cases they cover."
Who is this podcast for?
- ✓Cold case enthusiasts who love decades-old unsolved mysteries
Pros & cons
- +High binge factor — listeners consistently come back for more
About this podcast
James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman cover murders in small American towns, combining dark comedy with genuine research. One of the best comedy-true crime hybrids in the genre — funny without being disrespectful, and more thoroughly researched than most dedicated true crime shows.
Rate this podcast
Community reviews
0 reviewsWrite a quick review
No reviews yet. Be the first!
Frequently Asked Questions about Small Town Murder
What is Small Town Murder about?
James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman cover murders in small American towns, combining dark comedy with genuine research. One of the best comedy-true crime hybrids in the genre — funny without being disrespectful, and more thoroughly researched than most dedicated true crime shows.
Is Small Town Murder worth listening to?
Our editorial verdict is "Worth a listen". It scores 7/10 on binge factor. Dark comedy meets genuine research — murders in small American towns covered weekly with wit and care.
Who is Small Town Murder for?
Small Town Murder is ideal for: Cold case enthusiasts who love decades-old unsolved mysteries.
What is the best episode of Small Town Murder to start with?
Start with whichever case title sounds most interesting to you.
Where can I listen to Small Town Murder?
Small Town Murder is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify. Search for it by name on any of those apps.
What podcasts are similar to Small Town Murder?
If you enjoy Small Town Murder, you might also like: Serial, In the Dark, West Cork, Bear Brook. See our full "Podcasts Like Small Town Murder" page for more recommendations.
Quick facts
- Binge factor
- 7/10
- Country
- United States
Listen on
Browse category
Newsletter
Get weekly recommendations
Curated picks, new reviews, hidden gems.
If you liked this, try…
See all alternatives
Serial
Anyone interested in journalism, legal procedure, and deep investigative dives into morally ambiguous cases with no easy answers.
In the Dark
Listeners who want journalism-grade investigation into wrongful convictions, systemic racism, and institutional failures — more 60 Minutes than true crime thriller.
West Cork
True crime fans who love atmospheric investigative journalism, Anglo-Irish tensions, and cases that remain unresolved and fiercely contested decades later.
Bear Brook
True crime fans fascinated by forensic science, DNA technology, and cold cases with a genuine scientific payoff.
Missing and Murdered: Finding Cleo
CBC's Connie Walker investigates the Sixties Scoop through the disappearance of Cleo Semaganis Nicotine.
Your Own Backyard
Listeners who want investigative true crime with real-world consequence and single-minded, passionate focus from a creator who refused to let a case die.
Explore more in these categories: