Moms and Mysteries
True crime podcast review — 2026
Reviewed · Updated
"An accessible, community-built entry point for listeners new to the genre."
Who is this podcast for?
- ✓Listeners who prefer variety — a new case with every episode
Pros & cons
- +High binge factor — listeners consistently come back for more
- +Episodic format — great for both casual listeners and committed fans, start anywhere
About this podcast
Two Florida moms, hundreds of mysteries, and one obsession: 'How did this happen?' Mandy and Melissa bring listeners twice-a-week deep dives into true crime, from Florida's most bizarre cases to infamous mysteries further afield.
Best episode to start with
Episode 1
Episodic format — episodes can generally be enjoyed in any order
Rate this podcast
Community reviews
0 reviewsWrite a quick review
No reviews yet. Be the first!
Frequently Asked Questions about Moms and Mysteries
What is Moms and Mysteries about?
Two Florida moms, hundreds of mysteries, and one obsession: 'How did this happen?' Mandy and Melissa bring listeners twice-a-week deep dives into true crime, from Florida's most bizarre cases to infamous mysteries further afield.
Is Moms and Mysteries worth listening to?
Our editorial verdict is "Good if an accessible, everyday-perspective take on true crime appeals to you". It scores 7/10 on binge factor. Two Florida moms, Mandy and Melissa, bring twice-weekly deep dives into true crime — from Florida's most bizarre cases to infamous mysteries.
Who is Moms and Mysteries for?
Moms and Mysteries is ideal for: Listeners who prefer variety — a new case with every episode.
What is the best episode of Moms and Mysteries to start with?
We recommend starting with Episode 1. Episodes can generally be enjoyed in any order.
Where can I listen to Moms and Mysteries?
Moms and Mysteries is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify. Search for it by name on any of those apps.
What podcasts are similar to Moms and Mysteries?
If you enjoy Moms and Mysteries, you might also like: Crime Next Door: The Beast of Birkenhead, Foul Play: A Historical True Crime Podcast, In the Dark, Serial. See our full "Podcasts Like Moms and Mysteries" page for more recommendations.
Quick facts
- Format
- Episodic
- Host style
- Dual host
- Style
- Accessible, community-oriented, curious
- Episode length
- 40-55 min
- Episodes
- 100+ episodes
- Binge factor
- 7/10
- Country
- United States
Listen on
Browse category
Newsletter
Get weekly recommendations
Curated picks, new reviews, hidden gems.
You can unsubscribe anytime.
If you liked this, try…
See all alternatives
Crime Next Door: The Beast of Birkenhead
BBC’s Olivia Graham revisits the 1986 Diane Sindall murder and the 2025 quashing of Peter Sullivan’s conviction. Sullivan quashed 13 May 2025; killer unknown.
Foul Play: A Historical True Crime Podcast
Foggy gaslit streets. A quiet courtroom. And crimes that history tried to bury. <
In the Dark
Listeners who want journalism-grade investigation into wrongful convictions, systemic racism, and institutional failures — more 60 Minutes than true crime thriller.
Serial
Anyone interested in journalism, legal procedure, and deep investigative dives into morally ambiguous cases with no easy answers.
The Trial of Erin Patterson
The Crime Desk's courtroom coverage of the Erin Patterson 'mushroom murders' trial — one of the biggest cases of the decade.
Murdaugh Murders Podcast
Journalists Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell broke the Murdaugh family saga before it became a national story, and kept reporting it deeper than anyone else.
Explore more in these categories: