Investigate: Finding Priscilla podcast artwork
πŸ‡¦πŸ‡Ί AustraliaMissing PersonMurderInvestigative

Investigate: Finding Priscilla

True crime podcast review β€” 2026

Worth your time
Quick VerdictWorth your time
"Investigate: Finding Priscilla follows Tara Cassidy into the 2018 disappearance of Priscilla Brooten in Brisbane, a woman nobody reported missing for six months and whose body has never been found."

Who is this podcast for?

  • βœ“Listeners who enjoy following a single case from start to finish
  • βœ“Anyone fascinated by missing persons investigations
  • βœ“Fans of original investigative journalism over retold news
  • βœ“Listeners who enjoy a conversational, back-and-forth dynamic

Pros

Pros
  • +Serialized format builds a compelling, sustained narrative arc across episodes

About the host

Tara Cassidy and Amelia Oberhardt

Tara Cassidy and Amelia Oberhardt are Australian investigative journalists with more than three decades of combined crime reporting between them. Cassidy made Killer Charm after sitting through every day of the trial over Bruce Saunders' death; Oberhardt made the award-winning Shame, Lies & Families. Cassidy leads the Finding Priscilla season. Co-hosted show.

About this podcast

Finding Priscilla is the first season of Investigate, the new flagship from Tapt Media's Crime Central Australia. In July 2018, 46-year-old Priscilla Brooten, an American mother living in Brisbane, vanished, leaving an abandoned car behind. Nobody formally reported her missing until December, nearly six months later, and it was her friends who pushed police into action. Journalist Tara Cassidy retraces those lost months through interviews with Priscilla's daughter, her best friend, former classmates and people who knew her former partner, some speaking publicly for the first time. A man has since been convicted of her murder, but Priscilla's body has never been found, and the series is as much about her life and the people still searching for her as about the investigation. It runs to six episodes, released two at a time each week from 8 November 2026. Between seasons, hosts Tara Cassidy and Amelia Oberhardt plan weekly episodes on crime stories in the news. Content warning: suspected murder of a missing woman, controlling behaviour and sexual misconduct.

Best episode to start with

"1. Missing | Finding Priscilla" (8 Nov 2026); listen in order.

Serialized format β€” listen from the beginning for the full experience

Rate this podcast

Community reviews

0 reviews

Write a quick review

300 characters remaining

No reviews yet. Be the first!

Frequently Asked Questions about Investigate: Finding Priscilla

What is Investigate: Finding Priscilla about?

Finding Priscilla is the first season of Investigate, the new flagship from Tapt Media's Crime Central Australia. In July 2018, 46-year-old Priscilla Brooten, an American mother living in Brisbane, vanished, leaving an abandoned car behind. Nobody formally reported her missing until December, nearly six months later, and it was her friends who pushed police into action. Journalist Tara Cassidy retraces those lost months through interviews with Priscilla's daughter, her best friend, former classmates and people who knew her former partner, some speaking publicly for the first time. A man has since been convicted of her murder, but Priscilla's body has never been found, and the series is as much about her life and the people still searching for her as about the investigation. It runs to six episodes, released two at a time each week from 8 November 2026. Between seasons, hosts Tara Cassidy and Amelia Oberhardt plan weekly episodes on crime stories in the news. Content warning: suspected murder of a missing woman, controlling behaviour and sexual misconduct.

Is Investigate: Finding Priscilla worth listening to?

Our editorial verdict is "Worth your time". Fans of careful Australian investigative journalism who want a careful, victim-centred missing-person story told in six tight episodes. Less suited to listeners after fast, sensational storytelling.

Who is Investigate: Finding Priscilla for?

Investigate: Finding Priscilla is ideal for: Listeners who enjoy following a single case from start to finish; Anyone fascinated by missing persons investigations; Fans of original investigative journalism over retold news; Listeners who enjoy a conversational, back-and-forth dynamic.

What is the best episode of Investigate: Finding Priscilla to start with?

We recommend starting with "1. Missing | Finding Priscilla" (8 Nov 2026); listen in order.. As a serialized show, it's best to listen from the beginning of a season.

Where can I listen to Investigate: Finding Priscilla?

Investigate: Finding Priscilla is available on Apple Podcasts, RSS.

What podcasts are similar to Investigate: Finding Priscilla?

If you enjoy Investigate: Finding Priscilla, you might also like: Casefile True Crime, Secrets We Keep: Killer Charm, The Teacher's Pet, Crime & Conspiracies with Coffee. See our full "Podcasts Like Investigate: Finding Priscilla" page for more recommendations.

Quick facts

Format
Serialized
Host style
Dual Host
Style
Mixed
Episode length
About 28-38 min
Episodes
6-episode season; 4 out by 19 Nov 2026 (two a week from 8 Nov 2026), plus an intro, trailer and meet-the-hosts episode
Country
Australia

Liked this?

Podcasts Like Investigate: Finding Priscilla

Find your next obsession

Podcaster?

Show listeners this podcast has been independently reviewed.

Get your badge

Newsletter

Get weekly recommendations

Curated picks, new reviews, hidden gems.

You can unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.