Everything They Missed
True crime podcast review — 2026
Reviewed · Updated
"A wrongful-conviction investigation built around how quickly an official story can harden into fact."
Who is this podcast for?
- ✓Listeners who enjoy following a single case from start to finish
- ✓Fans of original investigative journalism over retold news
- ✓Legal procedure enthusiasts and wrongful conviction advocates
Pros & cons
- +High binge factor — listeners consistently come back for more
- +Serialized format builds a compelling, sustained narrative arc across episodes
- −Must listen in order — cannot dip in and out between episodes
About this podcast
It starts with a name — whispered in an interrogation room, scribbled into police reports, passed along like an absolute that seemed to solve everything, too neatly and too quickly. Everything They Missed, hosted by Stephanie Tinsley, pulls that thread to see what actually got overlooked.
Best episode to start with
Episode 1
Serialized format — listen from the beginning for the full experience
Rate this podcast
Community reviews
0 reviewsWrite a quick review
No reviews yet. Be the first!
Frequently Asked Questions about Everything They Missed
What is Everything They Missed about?
It starts with a name — whispered in an interrogation room, scribbled into police reports, passed along like an absolute that seemed to solve everything, too neatly and too quickly. Everything They Missed, hosted by Stephanie Tinsley, pulls that thread to see what actually got overlooked.
Is Everything They Missed worth listening to?
Our editorial verdict is "Good if wrongful-conviction investigations interest you". It scores 7/10 on binge factor. Independent journalist Stephanie Tinsley traces how a name whispered in an interrogation room hardened into an official story that may have been wrong from the start.
Who is Everything They Missed for?
Everything They Missed is ideal for: Listeners who enjoy following a single case from start to finish; Fans of original investigative journalism over retold news; Legal procedure enthusiasts and wrongful conviction advocates.
What is the best episode of Everything They Missed to start with?
We recommend starting with Episode 1. As a serialized show, it's best to listen from the beginning of a season.
Where can I listen to Everything They Missed?
Everything They Missed is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify. Search for it by name on any of those apps.
What podcasts are similar to Everything They Missed?
If you enjoy Everything They Missed, you might also like: Crime Next Door: The Beast of Birkenhead, Wrongful Conviction with Jason Flom, The Trial of Erin Patterson, S-Town. See our full "Podcasts Like Everything They Missed" page for more recommendations.
Quick facts
- Format
- Serialized
- Host style
- Solo narrator
- Style
- Investigative, serious, empathetic
- Episode length
- 35-45 min
- Episodes
- 17 episodes
- Binge factor
- 7/10
- Country
- United States
Listen on
Browse category
Newsletter
Get weekly recommendations
Curated picks, new reviews, hidden gems.
You can unsubscribe anytime.
If you liked this, try…
See all alternatives
Crime Next Door: The Beast of Birkenhead
BBC’s Olivia Graham revisits the 1986 Diane Sindall murder and the 2025 quashing of Peter Sullivan’s conviction. Sullivan quashed 13 May 2025; killer unknown.
Wrongful Conviction with Jason Flom
Jason Flom interviews the wrongfully convicted and their advocates to expose failures in the justice system.
The Trial of Erin Patterson
The Crime Desk's courtroom coverage of the Erin Patterson 'mushroom murders' trial — one of the biggest cases of the decade.
S-Town
From Serial Productions: a man convinced his Alabama town is covering up a murder pulls host Brian Reed into a story that becomes something else entirely.
Bone Valley
True crime fans who care deeply about wrongful conviction, prosecutorial failure, and the fight to free innocent people; fans of In the Dark will find this essential.
You Didn't See Nothin
Pulitzer Prize and Peabody Award-winning series in which Yohance Lacour revisits a violent Chicago incident from 25 years earlier that shaped his path into journalism.
Explore more in these categories: