True Crime Garage
True crime fans who enjoy laid-back, conversational coverage of a wide range of cases; the podcast equivalent of true crime over drinks with friends.
Podcasts Like True Crime Garage
If you loved True Crime Garage, here are the best podcasts to try next. Matched by case type, storytelling style, and community ratings from our database of Serial Killer, Cold Case, Missing Person, Murder shows.
Why listeners love True Crime Garage
True Crime Garage is the comfortable old friend of the true crime podcast world — Nic and the Captain have been delivering reliable weekly coverage since 2015, 914+ episodes and counting. Listeners rate its binge factor at 7/10.
Binge Factor
7/10
Community-rated compulsive listenability
Format
Episodic
New case with every episode
Style
Conversational, relaxed, occasionally humorous
Presentation approach
Episode Length
~60-90 min per episode; 914+ episodes since 2015; massive backlog
Typical episode duration
Host Style
Co-hosted
Presentation format
Verdict
Good if niche interests you
Our editorial rating
Recommendations
12 podcasts like True Crime Garage
Crime Junkie
True crime fans who want concise, well-researched episodes without excessive banter or filler; great for commuters.
Morbid
True crime fans who enjoy real forensic expertise delivered with warmth and humour; those who want both depth and a sense of fun.
My Favorite Murder
True crime fans who enjoy comedy and warm friendship chemistry alongside the darkness; especially popular with women; great for those who find straight true crime too heavy.
Southern Shadows
Community-focused true crime podcast sharing victim stories to raise awareness in Southern communities.
Hide and Seek
Serialised investigation of cold case disappearances, with each season dedicated to a single case.
The Knife: A True Crime Podcast
Exactly Right's investigation of stabbing and knife crime cases with sharp focus.
American Monster
Investigates the psychology behind killers who hide in plain sight as ordinary community members.
Foul Play: A Historical True Crime Podcast
<p><em>Foggy</em> <em>gaslit</em> <em>streets.</em> <em>A</em> <em>quiet</em> <em>courtroom.</em> <em>And</em> <em>crimes</em> <em>that</em> <em>history</em> <em>tried</em> <em>to</em> <em>bury.</em><
Crime Next Door: The Beast of Birkenhead
BBC’s Olivia Graham revisits the 1986 Diane Sindall murder and the 2025 quashing of Peter Sullivan’s conviction. Sullivan quashed 13 May 2025; killer unknown.
In the Dark
Listeners who want journalism-grade investigation into wrongful convictions, systemic racism, and institutional failures — more 60 Minutes than true crime thriller.
Serial
Anyone interested in journalism, legal procedure, and deep investigative dives into morally ambiguous cases with no easy answers.
The Trial of Erin Patterson
The Crime Desk's courtroom coverage of the Erin Patterson 'mushroom murders' trial — one of the biggest cases of the decade.
How they compare
| Podcast | Format | Country | Binge |
|---|---|---|---|
| True Crime Garage (original) | Episodic | United States | 7/10 |
| Crime Junkie | Episodic | United States | 6/10 |
| Morbid | Episodic | United States | 5/10 |
| My Favorite Murder | Episodic | United States | 5/10 |
| Southern Shadows | Serialised | United States | 8/10 |
| Hide and Seek | Serialised | United States | 7/10 |
| The Knife: A True Crime Podcast | Both | United States | 7/10 |
| American Monster | Serialised | United States | 8/10 |
| Foul Play: A Historical True Crime Podcast | — | — | — |
Newsletter
Get recommendations like this weekly
Curated picks, new reviews, and hidden gems. Find your next obsession.
You can unsubscribe anytime.
Frequently Asked Questions
What podcasts are similar to True Crime Garage?
The best alternatives to True Crime Garage are podcasts that share its Serial Killer, Cold Case, Missing Person, Murder focus and episodic format. Our editorial team has hand-picked the most similar shows based on content type, storytelling style, and community ratings.
Why do people love True Crime Garage?
True Crime Garage is known for its conversational, relaxed, occasionally humorous approach to Serial Killer and Cold Case. It scores 7/10 on our binge factor rating, reflecting how compulsively listenable listeners find it.
How long are episodes of True Crime Garage?
Episodes of True Crime Garage are typically ~60-90 min per episode; 914+ episodes since 2015; massive backlog long. It follows an episodic format, with each episode covering a different case.
Where can I listen to True Crime Garage?
True Crime Garage is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, iHeart. You can find it by searching the show name on any of those platforms.
What is the best episode of True Crime Garage to start with?
New listeners are recommended to start with Choose any case you're already interested in — the format works as standalone episodes. Episodes can generally be listened to in any order.